Green groups and politicians alike are criticizing the first Democratic primary debate moderated by NBC News on Wednesday night for failing to ask enough substantive climate change questions.
While debate moderators spent nearly 10 minutes asking various candidates about issues related to their climate action plans, critics who have been calling for a single climate-focused debate are arguing it was significantly lacking.
“I don’t think that we are discussing climate change the way we need to be discussing climate change,” Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) said on “The Late Show with Steven Colbert” after the debate.
“It is such a huge, broad systemic issue and you can’t just say, ‘Is Miami gonna exist in 50 years?’ We need to say what are you going to do about this.”
Candidates on the Miami stage were asked a variety of pin-pointed questions, including could their climate plans alone save Miami from sea level rise, how could they make carbon pricing economical and how they can spread the message of a climate crisis.
But critics argued the questions at times lacked important context and made large assumptions about the state of climate change, letting candidates answer with broad-strokes responses.
“It’s absurd to host a debate in Miami — a city where millions of people could lose their homes due to sea level rise that’s also only 20 miles from the Everglades, where massive fires are out of control — and spend only a few minutes on the climate crisis,” said Varshini Prakash, co-founder of the Sunrise Movement a youth-led climate action group.
“Only four candidates had the opportunity to discuss it at all. This is downright irresponsible and shameful.”
The group, along with other environmental organizations, has been asking for a stand-alone climate change debate. Activists with Sunrise staged an all-night sit-in earlier this week at Democratic National Committee (DNC) headquarters in Washington, D.C., to demand a climate debate.
But it wasn’t that candidates didn’t want to breach the issue of climate change, a topic that most have acknowledged is a global problem that needs addressing.
The first mention of climate change came within the first minute of the debate. Washington Gov. Jay Inslee
Jay Robert InsleeWinners and losers from two nights of Democratic debates Second Democratic debate largely steers clear of climate change Biden, Harris get most speaking time at second debate MORE, who has made the issue the central one of his campaign, mentioned energy sources when criticizing President Trump
Donald John TrumpSenate rejects attempt to curb Trump’s Iran war powers Sarah Sanders: I will walk out of the White House ‘with my head held high’ Atlanta mayor endorses Biden for president MORE for failing to embrace wind turbines.
“Donald Trump is simply wrong. He says they cause cancer. I say they cause jobs.”
Former Rep. John Delaney
John Kevin DelaneyDelaney mocks Democrats at second debate: ‘These people are terrible at interrupting’ Warren, Booker, Castro see favorability jump after first Democratic debate: poll Young Turks founder: ‘I actually really respect John Delaney’ MORE (D-Md.) attempted to jump in many times to highlight the fact that he co-sponsored the first congressional bill on carbon pricing.
And former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro and Sens. Elizabeth Warren
Elizabeth Ann WarrenHarris clarifies private insurance stance: ‘No, no’ I don’t think it should be eliminated The Hill’s Morning Report — Harris brings her A game to Miami debate Winners and losers from two nights of Democratic debates MORE (Mass.) and Cory Booker
Cory Anthony BookerBooker: Biden can’t ‘fall into a defensive crouch and shift blame’ Winners and losers from two nights of Democratic debates Biden, Harris get most speaking time at second debate MORE (N.J.) all mentioned climate change when asked to name the biggest geopolitical threat facing the U.S.
Critics, however, took issue with the fact that debate questions didn’t get to climate change until nearly an hour and a half through the event.
The issue of the Green New Deal, the progressive climate plan championed by Ocasio-Cortez and several Democratic hopefuls, was never mentioned by name.
Nevertheless, DNC Chairman Tom Perez
Thomas Edward PerezClinton’s top five vice presidential picks Government social programs: Triumph of hope over evidence Labor’s ‘wasteful spending and mismanagement” at Workers’ Comp MORE pointed out that the debate had more discussion about climate than any before.
“Is that enough? Absolutely not, but we have already done tonight more than we did in 2016,” he said, according to Politico. “I said repeatedly we will talk about climate change early, often, and in depth. We saw that down payment tonight.”
